GET STARTED | Access Our Properties List Today

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

How to Find, Finance, and Manage Your First Rental Property in Milwaukee

Real estate investing can be a lucrative way to generate passive income and build long-term wealth. However, for many first-time investors, the process of finding, financing, and managing a rental property can be overwhelming. In this blog, we will guide you through the process of investing in a rental property in Milwaukee, with a focus on how Northwoods Property Resources‘s team of buyers can help you find the perfect properties for your budget, goals, and lifestyle.

Step 1: Define Your Investment Goals

Before you start looking for a rental property, you need to define your investment goals. Ask yourself questions such as:

– What is your budget?

– What kind of rental property do you want to invest in (single-family, multifamily, commercial, etc.)?

– What is your expected return on investment (ROI)?

– Do you plan to manage the property yourself or hire a property management company to manage the tenants and property on your behalf?

– How long do you plan to hold the property?

Once you have a clear understanding of your investment goals, you can start looking for properties that match your criteria. You’ll want to have all of these things in mind to help narrow your focus when buying investment property in Milwaukee. 

Step 2: Find the Right Property

Finding the right rental property can be challenging, especially in a competitive market like Milwaukee, where prices have seen steady appreciation in neighborhoods like Bay View and Walker’s Point. As a first-time investor, understanding market trends is essential to avoid overpaying or buying in areas with lower demand. For instance, properties in Riverwest have shown strong rental growth, with rental yields increasing by 5% annually in recent years, while areas like East Side are popular but tend to have higher initial purchase costs.
Working with local experts can streamline the process. A well-versed team will help you identify undervalued properties, especially those that may need slight renovations but offer excellent rental potential. Additionally, leveraging market data, like recent sales trends and neighborhood-level reports, will allow you to make informed decisions. At Northwoods Property Resources, we provide our clients with access to comprehensive market analyses and property reports, including cash flow projections, ROI estimates, and neighborhood insights. These resources enable you to make calculated, data-backed decisions on your investment.

Step 3: Financing Your Rental Property

Financing your rental property is another critical aspect of real estate investing. In Milwaukee, traditional mortgages are a popular choice for first-time investors due to their stability, especially with interest rates currently hovering around 6% for 30-year fixed loans. However, some investors may prefer more flexible or faster options, like hard money loans, which can offer quick access to capital but often come with higher interest rates (typically 10-12%). These loans are especially useful for properties in need of renovations that would make them ineligible for conventional financing.
You’ll also want to consider creative financing options such as seller financing, where the property owner acts as the lender, or portfolio loans, which allow investors to finance multiple properties under one mortgage. At Northwoods Property Resources, we not only connect you with lenders but also provide detailed financial comparisons, including monthly payments, cash-on-cash returns, and how each financing option could impact your overall return on investment. Understanding the long-term implications of your financing decision is crucial to ensuring a profitable investment.

Step 4: Managing Your Rental Property

Managing a rental property can be both rewarding and challenging, especially if you are new to real estate investing. In Milwaukee, landlords are responsible for a range of tasks, from tenant screening and lease renewals to ensuring compliance with local ordinances, such as maintaining building safety standards and adhering to lead-paint disclosure laws. For a first-time investor, these tasks can quickly become overwhelming.
Working with a property management service can alleviate much of this burden. A good property manager will not only handle routine tasks like rent collection and tenant communication but will also help minimize vacancies by effectively marketing your property to prospective tenants. In a competitive rental market like Milwaukee, where vacancy rates are as low as 4%, a proactive approach to tenant retention can save you significant costs over time.
Additionally, property management companies offer crucial 24/7 emergency services. Whether it’s a burst pipe in the middle of winter or an unexpected electrical issue, having a dedicated team ensures that your property and tenants are well cared for. At Northwoods Property Resources, we recommend property management partners who specialize in tenant relations, property maintenance, and legal compliance, so you can focus on growing your investment portfolio with peace of mind.

Taking the Next Steps

Taking the Next Steps
Real estate investing can be a lucrative path toward generating passive income and building long-term wealth. However, for first-time investors, navigating the Milwaukee rental market’s unique challenges—from rising property values to fluctuating vacancy rates—can be daunting. It’s important to remember that thorough research and careful planning are key to a successful investment.
Whether you’re looking to purchase a single-family home in up-and-coming neighborhoods like Brewer’s Hill or a multifamily property in Walker’s Point, understanding your long-term goals and risk tolerance is crucial. Securing the right financing, ensuring a high-quality tenant base, and managing the property effectively are all components that will determine the profitability of your investment.

If you’re ready to invest in a rental property in Milwaukee, contact Northwoods Property Resources today to schedule a consultation with our team of experts. We are committed to helping you achieve your investment goals and build long-term wealth through real estate investing. Give us a call at (920) 851-9727 today to learn more about what we can offer you! 

Looking For Investment Properties?

Fill out the form below to join our "Preferred Property Buyers" list and for local real estate updates too!

Enter Your Information Below To Get Immediate Access

... to our HANDYMAN specials. *These are not on the MLS - Many are below $100k. Available properties on the next page.

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.